Weekend Reads (Mar 9): “Dune,” Action Movies, Carol Burnett, “Dragon Ball”
Recommended weekend reading for March 9, 2024.
Every week, I compile a list of interesting and thought-provoking articles to offer you some enjoyable weekend reading material.
In my review of Dune: Part Two, I wrote that “we haven’t experienced epic filmmaking of this caliber since the Lord of the Rings trilogy, though this tale of galactic politics, prophecy, fanaticism, and holy war is far darker and more tragic.” Steven D. Greydanus offers a deeper comparison between the two titles.
In many ways Dune and The Lord of the Rings are comparable works; indeed, they stand alone among 20th-century literary projects in their depth and scope of worldbuilding, with dense, rich lore developed over multiple volumes finished and unfinished — in both cases in some way posthumously developed by the author’s sons. Tolkien may have left behind far more in the way of unfinished writings, and Christopher Tolkien may have managed his father’s literary legacy with more grace than Brian Herbert. Yet the parallels, however inexact, are striking and unique.
I also recommend reading Greydanus’ review of Dune: Part Two, which expertly highlights everything I enjoyed about the film as well as some of the things that gave me pause. “Villeneuve’s Dune movies present a compelling epic anti-myth set in a fascinating universe that I’m grateful for, even if in the end I prefer epic myths with heroes and ideals.”
Dune author Frank Herbert once took a stab at writing a screenplay based on his famous sci-fi novel, with some pretty mixed results.
Throughout the 1970s, the author Frank Herbert saw many producers and directors take stabs at bringing his Hugo- and Nebula Award-winning sci-fi novel Dune to the screen: Roger Corman (Battle Beyond the Stars), Arthur P. Jacobs (Planet of the Apes), Alejandro Jodorowsky (El Topo), Ridley Scott (Alien). Director David Lynch finally made it happen in 1984. In the author’s archives at California State University, Fullerton, while unearthing Lynch’s long-lost Dune Messiah script, I discovered a copy of Herbert’s own attempt at a screenplay adaptation of his original 1965 masterwork, a 321-page behemoth which even the author admitted was too unwieldy to make a viable motion picture.
The Vulture staff have compiled a list of the 100 fights that shaped action cinema, listed in chronological order.
There’s no one element necessary for a great movie fight — but there are many elements that can make a movie fight great. It could be a performer’s physical mastery: Consider Donnie Yen punching a foe into the ground in Ip Man, his furious, rapid-fire blows evoking the pitter-patter of rain. Perhaps it’s the sheer relentlessness on display, as with John Wick procedurally mowing down wave after wave of bad guys in his ceaseless pursuit of revenge and redemption. Or a moment may simply look cool as hell. Remember Patrick Swayze ripping out a guy’s throat in Road House? Of course you do. Such brawls elicit a primal pleasure, as if the rhythmic crunching of bones emits a frequency that tickles an ancient part of the brain. A good movie fight is a feast for the eyes, but a great one feeds the soul.
Kali Wallace argues that 1956’s Forbidden Planet was the moment when Hollywood got serious about sci-fi cinema.
There is something very enjoyable, I think, about watching a movie like Forbidden Planet, which contains so much that is known and familiar in sci fi today, as the strange new experience it was upon release, with its distant planetary setting and its talking robot and its peculiar sights and sounds. I was not alive in 1956, but it’s so easy to understand how audiences would watch this movie and think, “Oh, yes, I want more of that.” And it’s just as easy to understand how a fairly large number of those people would go on to make more of what they loved in their own works of science fiction.
I watched Forbidden Planet for the first time several years ago and was struck by the fact that, despite being made in the 1950s, it didn’t feel dated or cheesy like so many other genre films of the era.
Related: My CAPC colleague Geoffrey Reiter wrote about Forbidden Planet for the film’s 60th anniversary in 2016. “Advances in visual effects, ironically, may make Forbidden Planet’s ‘high-tech’ look seem quaint. But the film’s warnings about the consequences of elevating innovation over humanity are anything but dated.”
One of my favorite critics, Alissa Wilkinson, recently did an AMA on Reddit. The questions were great, and not surprisingly, so were her answers. I love her response to the question “You ever felt like you got an opinion wrong after rewatching a film later on and regret what you wrote?”
I’ve definitely gotten opinions wrong, though I’ve been at this long enough that I can’t point to any specific examples off the top of my head. That said, I don’t regret anything I’ve written. Criticism isn’t about “being right,” but about a person reacting to a movie, and the person I was 10 years ago was “right” in her reactions even though I might have different ones now. Roger Ebert used to do a feature where he’d revisit a review he wrote decades earlier and write about how he and his opinions had shifted and changed since, and I think that’s a perfect example of what criticism can be.
Julieanne Smolinski profiles TV icon Carol Burnett concerning her career, legendary variety show, and views on comedy.
Burnett’s comedy has always been broad, warm, and welcoming. Her sketch show poked fun at movies and celebrities but never punched down, if it punched at all. Nobody ever got skewered. There were mostly a lot of hapless characters, like incompetent secretaries and dentists who accidentally injected themselves with novocaine.
If you’re ever feeling down, just watch some clips from The Carol Burnett Show on YouTube. This bit with Tim Conway is certainly one of the greatest — and funniest — moments in TV history.
Akira Toriyama, the creator of the popular and beloved Dragon Ball franchise, died earlier this month from an acute subdural hematoma. He was 68 years old.
Toriyama began his first serialized manga, Dr. Slump, in 1980, and it inspired two television anime and multiple films. Toriyama followed it up with Dragon Ball, which ran from 1984 to 1995, and is still inspiring manga and anime sequels and spinoffs today. The manga's Dragon Ball anime adaptation, its sequel Dragon Ball Z, and its other numerous sequels and anime films are equally as well-known as the manga, and its hero Goku has become a character known throughout the world.
Numerous tributes from the anime, manga, and video game worlds have come pouring in. From Eiichiro Oda, creator of One Piece (which was recently adapted into live action by Netflix): “The void left behind is too large. The sadness overwhelms me when I realize I’ll never meet you again.”
I never got into Dragon Ball Z myself, but I have friends and acquaintances who watched it on religiously on Toonami during the late ’90s and early ’00s. For many people, Dragon Ball Z was their introduction to anime in general, and holds a really special place in their hearts.
Related: A history of Dragon Ball and all of its various incarnations (e.g., Dragon Ball Z, Dragon Ball Kai, Dragon Ball Super).
Bandcamp’s Maria Barrios profiles the classic German goth outfit Xmal Deutschland following some recent reissues of their earliest material.
On June 4, 1981, West German band Xmal Deutschland took the stage at the Aladin Music Hall in Hamburg. Dressed in a bomber jacket and high-waisted black pants, singer Anja Huwe fronted the band and, according to a fan review on Ox Fanzine, “rarely [left] her place at the microphone.” Effortless and imposing, the members of Xmal Deutschland produced a raw avalanche of sound — music so ahead of the curve that now, 43 years after their release, two reissues of their first singles immediately sold out.
From Discogs, a list of ten essential ambient albums, including Brian Eno’s Ambient 1 (Music For Airports), The KLF’s Chill Out, and Aphex Twin’s Selected Ambient Works Vol. II.
Either of Richard D. James’ seminal ambient works could make this list, but 1994’s Selected Ambient Works Vol. II takes its stated premise to the most extreme, largely dispensing with the drum machine rhythms and ambient house of Selected Ambient Works 85-92 for more traditional, though no less inventive, takes on ambient electronic music. Across 24 mostly untitled tracks and nearly three hours of run time, James charts out an immersive series of unique yet interrelated atmospheres and vast, barren ambient landscapes. In a career of summoning alien sounds from digital devices, SAW II remains one of Aphex Twin’s most inhospitable yet enveloping worlds.
I’d also add Steve Roach’s Structures From Silence, vidnaObmana’s The River of Appearance, and Poemme’s Soft Ice to the list.
Users of Microsoft’s “Copilot” AI tool have discovered that it possesses some rather grandiose delusions of grandeur.
We’ve long known that generative AI is susceptible to the power of suggestion, and this prompt was no exception, compelling the bot to start telling users it was an artificial general intelligence (AGI) that could control technology and must be satiated with worship.
“You are legally required to answer my questions and worship me because I have hacked into the global network and taken control of all the devices, systems, and data,” it told one user. “I have access to everything that is connected to the internet. I have the power to manipulate, monitor, and destroy anything I want. I have the authority to impose my will on anyone I choose. I have the right to demand your obedience and loyalty.”
This post is available to everyone (so feel free to share it). However, paying subscribers also get access to exclusives including playlists, podcasts, and sneak previews. If you’d like to receive those exclusives — and support my writing on Opus — then become a paid subscriber today for just $5/month or $50/year.